General Discussion

Originally posted by Netzoko

Every FTP game is disappointing.

 

#1: Age of Conan

#2: Pirates of the Burning Sea

#3: WAR

I second that!

Age of Conan

Tabula Rasa

LOTRO, at least near launch it was, haven't played since. If the combat has changed then I will remove this once I try again.

1.WOW

2.DDO

3.Dark and Light

Anything fantasy based.

Worst games so far...

AoC (72)

War (43)

Vanguard (40)

Tabula Rasa (29)

SWG (23)

LOTRO (22)

EQ2 (21)

DDO (20)

WoW (18)

Pirates (18)

... It sure hasn't been a good couple years for MMO releases!

Honorable mention to the two mainstream MMO's never mention (UO, DAoC) and the one only mentioned once (EQ (original))

---

Originally posted by Aetherial
Worst games so far...
AoC (72)
War (43)
Vanguard (40)
Tabula Rasa (29)
SWG (23)
LOTRO (22)
EQ2 (21)
DDO (20)
WoW (18)
Pirates (18)
... It sure hasn't been a good couple years for MMO releases!
Honorable mention to the two mainstream MMO's never mention (UO, DAoC) and the one only mentioned once (EQ (original))
 
 

---

First this is about most disappointing games not worst.
Second, another mainstreamm MMO not mentioned is FFXI, one of my all time favs.

Originally posted by elocke

 

---

Originally posted by Aetherial
Worst games so far...
AoC (72)
War (43)
Vanguard (40)
Tabula Rasa (29)
SWG (23)
LOTRO (22)
EQ2 (21)
DDO (20)
WoW (18)
Pirates (18)
... It sure hasn't been a good couple years for MMO releases!
Honorable mention to the two mainstream MMO's never mention (UO, DAoC) and the one only mentioned once (EQ (original))
 
 

---

 

First this is about most disappointing games not worst.
Second, another mainstreamm MMO not mentioned is FFXI, one of my all time favs.

FF was mentioned more than once... just not on my top ten list.

I would argue that there would be a very strong correlation between the most disappointing games and the worst games, unless the discussion was purely about technical merit.

Originally posted by Vidir

1.WOW

2.DDO

3.Dark and Light

You're seriously suggesting that WoW was a bigger disappointment than D&L?

I've seen everything now!

Originally posted by Wrender

Well this proves it for me ...Most of you people are just plain ignorant when it comes to MMO's. Thanks!

I agree with you 100%. All these people on a MMO forum and I would say every MMO has been brought up many of times. If you are so dissapointed in MMO's then move to single player games.

I agree that theres some MMO's out there that were a dissapointment, but some people on here have posted MMO's that were very good and succeded in what they wanted to do.

Everyone seems to want this perfect MMO. Its not going to happen.

1. AoC, by far

2. Vanguard

3. Tabula Rasa