Tidal Tribe Review

User Rating: 5.5
Tidal Tribe Review

One thing is absolutely obvious when starting Tidal Tribe – it is a massive venture for a single person.  There are no AAA, crack graphics squads putting together life-like worlds.  Rather, the developer is a programmer, artist, writer, and everything else under the sun to get this game off of the ground.  Although truly impressive in scope, the downside is that visuals (and some other facets of the game) do suffer.  On the other hand, the game is very lightweight and runs like a dream.  The music is very good and very soothing, so even if the graphics seem like a blast from the past, it’s not difficult to get lost in the sound. This is our Tidal Tribe review.

The game is split between the overworld, which is a two-dimensional map with specific destinations and paths, whereas the god game portion is a fully 3-d world.  The 2-d artwork is ok, reminiscent of older flash games.  Some mini-games share this art style, so expect to see it if you play the story campaigns.

Tidal Tribe Review 1

That leads me to what is probably Tidal Tribe’s greatest asset – its calm and peaceful nature.  We often live life at a breakneck pace and it’s sometimes nice to take some time to relax.  Tidal Tribe generally promotes a nearly Zen state where you simply try to remain aware of what’s happening to your people in-game.  Not all of the game modes or mini-games do this, but you’ll likely spend the lion’s share of your time in this game moving earth around, so expect a healthy dose of peace while you play.

The powers that you have are rather limited.  As mentioned, you can move earth, which you’ll do to open pathways for water, which encourages plant growth, which your people need to survive and thrive.  A detailed in-game wiki provides help as needed, so you know what conditions each of the plentitudes of plants require to grow.  A detailed, customizable map also helps you track your people and plants as you encourage population growth and advancement.  Upgrades in missions help your people to collect more fruit, build faster, not kill themselves out of despair, among many other boosts.

Tidal Tribe Review 2

The story campaign has five levels spread across an island that also features mini-games such as the Tidal Tribe’s ‘parkour’ levels (i.e., speed runs through waypoints on a map).  Mini-games can provide experience, which you can use to empower your avatar, thus increasing flight, running, or swimming speed.

The campaign’s story is another reminder that this is a one-man show.  That is, Tidal Tribe’s writing dances back and forth across the line between ‘indie’ and ‘amateur.’  That may be harsh, but I feel that a development team may have been able to better manage the story, the length of each story segment, and the quality of writing.

Tidal Tribe Review 3

I really like the depth that the game offers.  Learning how the plants interact and how to make them grow was fun for me.  I also enjoyed flying overhead and shifting the land’s ecosystem just by building or removing walls of sand.  The parkour levels were ok, but I felt they were less fun and more training for fine-tuned movement.  Relatedly, I preferred to use a controller for all of these activities and generally found the game optimized for controller use.

A final word about bugs – they do exist, and I hope that the developer is able to address them.  None were necessarily game killing, but things like being able to see the name of the earthmoving tool you’ll use in a free game, just like you do in a story game, would be nice.  Aside from those few bugs, though, the game is surprisingly well polished.

COMPARE TO: Black and White, Populous, Godus

A code was provided for the purpose of review.

Summary
Tidal Tribe is a god game but thrives as a Zen experience.  A broad and unique offering, the game could benefit from increased focus and better writing.  The game will not likely make any ‘greatest games’ lists, but that shouldn’t take away from how impressive it is that one individual developed this, and Tidal Tribe is not a bad game by any stretch.  It lacks the charm of classic god games like Black and White, yet it has a surprising degree of depth that invites further exploration.  This is a game to play if you want to relax and enjoy low-stakes society building.  If you want action or violence of any sort, you’re better off looking elsewhere. 
Good
  • Surprisingly deep gameplay
  • Very peaceful gaming experience
  • Great musical score
Bad
  • Hit-or-miss writing
  • Game lacks focus at times
  • Some bugs detract from the experience
5.5
Average

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Lost Password

Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.